| Prev Recipe | | | All Recipes.. | | | Next Recipe |
Phulka, Fulka, Phulki, Roti are only some of the names given to this wonderful Indian unleavened bread. We at ShowMeTheCurry will refer to it as ‘Phulka’ – a staple in most Indian households and enjoyed on an everyday basis. The look my kids get on their faces when the Phulka balloons up and the ‘Wow’ each and every time are the small pleasures in life!
Prep Time: 10 min
Cook Time: 15 min
Makes: 8-10 phulkas
Ingredients:
Whole Wheat Chapati Flour – 1.5 cups
Warm Water – 2/3rd cup
Chapati Flour – for dusting
Method:
1. Pour the Chapatti flour in a big open mixing bowl.
2. Pour the Warm Water a little at a time and start kneading.
3. Knead till the dry flour is all absorbed and it forms a nice dough.
4. Use a couple of drops of Oil and rub on the dough so it does not form a crust.
5. Cover and allow the dough to rest for about 15 minutes.
6. After 15 minutes, uncover and pinch a bit of the dough, about the size of a golf ball.
7. Form a round ball and flatten between the palm of your hands.
8. Roll it in the dry flour and dust off all excess flour.
9. Put it on the rolling surface and start rolling with a rolling pin.
10. Dip in the dry flour as needed to avoid sticking to the surface.
11. Make round phulkas.
12. Meanwhile, heat the Tawa/Skillet on medium heat.
13. Once it is nice and hot, lay the phulka on the Tawa.
14. Allow it to cook and flip once you see bubbles appear.
15. Allow it to cook for another minute.
16. Increase the flame to the maximum.
17. With the help of tongs, pick up the Phulka and place the flip side on the flame.
18. Allow it to balloon up and flip again.
19. Once you see a few brown spots appear on the Phulka, take it off.
20. Smear some ghee or butter and it’s ready to serve hot.
Tips:
1. The dough can be made in a food processor as well.
2. These are best served hot, but if you are going to be serving them a little later, invest in a hot case.
| Prev Recipe | | | All Recipes.. | | | Next Recipe |
| Pin It | Tweet |
|
![]() Stay informed |
Similar Recipes:
- Missi Roti aka Daal Roti
Have you ever had just a little bit of Daal leftover and you didn’t know what to do with it? Maybe it wasn’t even enough...
- Tandoori Roti
Tandoori Roti is another type of Indian unleavened bread which is usually made in a clay oven called a tandoor and commonly enjoyed with chicken,...
- Paneer Paratha – Stuffed Bread
Here’s another great way to use paneer – Paneer Paratha. This Indian unleavened and pan-fried bread is stuffed with spiced homemade cheese (paneer). It’s delicious...
- Rotli (Roti) Indian Bread Recipe
Rotli or Roti is yet another type of unleavened Indian bread that can be enjoyed with any vegetable or curry. Rotli, as they are known...
- Spinach Paratha
Spinach Paratha is a perfect way to enjoy the goodness of spinach. This Indian recipe for unleavened flat bread is a little different from the...



Youtube
Facebook
Twitter
Orkut
July 30th, 2009 at 5:23 am
hi anuja & hetal
I just love ur phulka balloon up. Its fantastic. but for me its very rare that 10 of 1 phulka balloons up. I’ve got a electric stove/heater, and after 3-4 phulkas it start like burning,thn i’ve to slow down it for sometime.so dnt have a option to place it on fire. Can u show without putting it on fire?
[Reply]
Satya Reply:
July 30th, 2009 at 5:13 pm
Noor,
With electric stove – use two stoves one… One for the tawa and the other one for ballooning up (put a mesh on this one and leave it on high).. The problem with electric vs gas is electric cools and heats up really slowly and if you wait that long your roti will dry out or burn up!
Also one big reason for your roti to not balloon up is if your tawa is too hot or too cold… leave the tawa stove on med high.
I would highly recommend investing in a food processor.. I have had great rotis even with durum atta when i knead it in a food processor! It is so much better than manually kneading it and faster!
[Reply]
July 30th, 2009 at 10:41 am
very good. thanks
[Reply]
July 30th, 2009 at 12:46 pm
Disclaimer: I am not criticizing you guys.
Hi,
I have been watching your videos way back and hats off to you guys.You have been really doing a very good job.
Since last 1-2 months the choice of your recipes have not been up to the mark to your own set standards.
Please take it as a positive feedback and no hard feelings …
One of your followers…..
[Reply]
July 30th, 2009 at 1:31 pm
Hi,
Can you please make onion kulcha, I had this one time in a restaurant and they were heavenly. Also, you list must be very long because I still haven’t seen any of my requests that were made months ago. Which also make me wonder, are all your recipes made only from requests???
I just can’t imagine people requesting some of the recipes that are shown. I know you try to cover every aspect of Indian culture from all over India, however I feel some of the recipes are very disappointing.
I am a huge fan of your site and I am always eager to know what you’re going to show next and some recipes are not up to par with the talent both of you have shown.
I still have lots of love for both of you.
[Reply]
anuja Reply:
July 31st, 2009 at 1:39 pm
Pinal,
Most of the stuff we show are requests. We have been getting requests from the day we started the website and put off some of the basic stuff thinking everyone knows it! But for some one just starting out, these recipes are life savers.
We understand your frustration and don’t want to ignore ‘anyone’ . Please bear with us and we are limited as far as time (both of us are Full Time Moms) and hopefully we’ll get yo your requests as well.
Thanks for your support and understanding.
[Reply]
Pinal Reply:
August 3rd, 2009 at 5:10 pm
Thanks Anuja for the feedback. My comments were not based on the simplicity of the recipes, but more so on the dish(es) itself. I can understand that every region has a dish that is popular to that region, but to me some dishes looked very unappetizing and there fore couldn’t imagine someone requesting it.
None the less, if they are requests than I understand that you are catering to your fan base.
[Reply]
Satya Reply:
August 3rd, 2009 at 3:07 pm
I agree with Pinal and Seena…
Lately you have very basic recipes(I am sure a lot of beginners are looking for those) – earlier you had some fab and extraordinary recipes that were hit at parties and at home… waiting for some of those kinds eagerly!!
We understand you are 24 *7 moms which to me is the toughest job on earth!! But you had set a standard in your fan club and guess what we are asking is to stay put at that!!
[Reply]
Priya Reply:
August 4th, 2009 at 10:11 pm
Dear Pinal and Satya,
You may be correct at ur end and trust me Hetal Anuja are right from their side. I really dont know which recipe you mentioned that looked unappetizing but trust me making roti,phulkas,parathas may look really easy but they need practice practice and practice!!! I being a house wife, could make only a year after i came to US.
Standard…hmm..Even making tea is a big issue for newbees! This site is for everyone and not only for already talented cooks. Also,do u think there are many out there who provide charity service like hetal and anuja. They dont expect a penny from us..rather…go and spend on grocery and teach us stuff! They broadcast for free..though they may have advertised for their DVD,aprons etc..but at the same time they haven forced us to buy them. Have they.
Look ladies..dont get angry..jus like..im their follower..and i just told my point.
Please..its really tough to maintain a family and do this stuff!
If u think u have some wonderful recipes which u think may improve and keep up their standard…do share them. I have already shared from my side.
Im sorry if i hurt..it was purely unintentional.
Priya
[Reply]
Pinal Reply:
August 7th, 2009 at 3:17 pm
Thanks Priya for also adding your opinion like I did mine. I too have a family and have a career oriented full time job and cook every day. I am too a new wife in a new home of my own. I actually like it when they provide recipes on rotis, paratha, etc….I just happen to make my comments under this recipe. I have been making rotis and many other basic recipes since I was 10 yrs of age, BUT that still doesn’t undermine some of the things I have learned from them even when it comes to making such simple recipes.
Again, my comments were not about the simple recipes but about certain dishes and I have already explained that in my previous comment. And, actually there are many, I mean MANY websites that provide recipes and similar services they do, but I also think that they are the BEST out there.
I am not dogging them or there hard work, so don’t take it so personally – they are not. I am also a follower of them, but I shared MY OPINION which is allowed in America.
July 30th, 2009 at 3:44 pm
Hello Ladies
Nice recipe…..Thanks…..Can you please show us how to make homemade naan…..
[Reply]
July 30th, 2009 at 5:16 pm
hii can u show how to make phulkas on electric stove…. u r phulkas are excellent.can u show on electric stove
[Reply]
July 31st, 2009 at 1:09 am
hi satya,
its realy a very good idea. thanx.
and yes i’ve got a food processor.
[Reply]
July 31st, 2009 at 7:41 am
Good one!
[Reply]
August 1st, 2009 at 1:17 pm
I envy people who have gas flame stoves.Can you please suggest how I can get the same effect of puffing up phulkas/rotis when using an electric coil stove. Thanx.
[Reply]
veera Reply:
September 9th, 2010 at 3:58 am
Use mesh. you get it in many indian stores. they call it ‘jaali’. i hv got awesome results with that. i even use it for roasting papad.
[Reply]
August 2nd, 2009 at 4:01 pm
Hi, I have an electric stove as well, and I use a mesh screen with a handle called a splatter screen. You can get it in the kitchen gadget section of Walmart and it’s very inexpensive. Mine came with two screens one smaller one large. If you use a second “eye” on the stove, you simply turn it on high, and when you remove the phulka from the tawa put it on your mesh screen and hold it almost on the electric coil. It may take a few seconds more to puff up but works surprisingly well. I normally was only getting one out of ten to puff up. Now most of them puff up! Hope this helps.
[Reply]
August 4th, 2009 at 12:01 am
Thanks Judy, will give it a try this weekend. I wish Hetal and Anuja can show a video demo for the procedure sometime in the future.
[Reply]
August 8th, 2009 at 5:18 pm
i notice you roll out your chapati on stainless steel.. is this a lid or a special board ?
[Reply]
hetal Reply:
August 8th, 2009 at 10:35 pm
We have used a rolling board that was purchased in India. Some of the larger Indian grocery stores may carry a similar product. Other options for rolling are a marble lazy susan or Sil Pat silicone baking sheet.
[Reply]
August 10th, 2009 at 5:38 pm
Dear Hetal & Anuja
I made phulkas yesterday and each one of them ballooned up so good. What a jot to see it puffing up. I was so excited about my perfect phulkas and my family was really surprised that I could ( being a south Indian) make their favorite dish flawless. Thank you so much for your wonderful way of demonstrating it. You girls gave me the courage to make it possible otherwise I wouldn’t have even thought of making it. THANK YOU!!! YOU REALLY ARE AWESOME.
P.S. Can you pl. come up with kids lunch box (vegetarian) ideas, they really don’t like to take our Indian food especially the dishes made with rice.
Thanks in advance
Love
Krithika
[Reply]
hetal Reply:
August 11th, 2009 at 2:03 pm
Hi Krithika,
Thanks so much for your lovely feedback. It always makes us so happy to hear some success stories. We’ll keep the lunch box ideas in mind. Thanks again!
[Reply]
August 11th, 2009 at 3:30 pm
Dear Hetal
Thanks a lot for your immediate reply amidst of your busy schedule.
Love
Subha.B
[Reply]
August 11th, 2009 at 4:33 pm
Pinal,Sorry if i hurt u. I just expressed my opinion. Well, i really didnt take it personal. Just felt bad since im a person who is like very grateful to these two wonderful ladies since they have improved my life so much…i really cannot explain in words. If at all we get to meet each other in any other social site , i would tell u.
No hard feelings…
And take care.
Priya
[Reply]
Pinal Reply:
August 11th, 2009 at 5:41 pm
Hi Priya,
No, you didn’t hurt me, but I felt I needed to also express my side of things. I actually understand where you are coming from. I am not a newbie in cooking but I am not a pro either. Also, I have been a newbie in many other things and understand it’s not always easy learning something new and how gratifying it is when it becomes a success.
I am also very grateful to them as I am also learning new wonderful recipes or a quicker way of making some of my old favorite dishes.
Best of luck to you.
[Reply]
Priya Reply:
August 13th, 2009 at 4:13 pm
Thanks Pinal. You are so kind. Keep it up!!
TC..
Priya
[Reply]
August 12th, 2009 at 1:09 pm
Dear Hetal & Anuja,
Is to Ok to cook directly on gas stove? I heard that it is not good for health. I used to make Nann using the cooker over direct heat but my friends told me that not to use it directly.
When i saw your phulka receipe, i noticed that u are cooking directly on gas. Please reply.
Thanks!
geetha.
[Reply]
hetal Reply:
August 12th, 2009 at 3:18 pm
Hi Geetha,
Most people say you should not cook over an open flame because the food may get overly charred — this charred substance is said to be carcinogenic. As long as you don’t burn the phulka, it should be fine.
[Reply]
October 15th, 2009 at 8:11 pm
Hello Hetal & Anuja,
) Tht is indeed a sweet Diwali begining!
success with making phulka is SWEET!!!! EVERY ONE of them puffed up !!!
I had a question though:
1.Can I make the dough and referigerate it so that I dont have to knead twice in one day ?
2.If yes, then how do I store it(do i need to put it in plastic wrap ) and how early do I need to take it out of the referigerator before making the phlkas?
Thanks and best wishes,
Shalmali
[Reply]
anuja Reply:
October 15th, 2009 at 9:36 pm
Hi Shalmali,
Sweet Diwali, indeed! To top it off, here is a video to demonstrate on how to make and freeze atta in bulk:
http://showmethecurry.com/breads/chapatti-dough-in-bulk.html
As far as storing in the fridge goes, the answer is yes, you can. The atta stays good for a couple of days. We suggest you pull it out of the fridge a couple of hours before to bring it down to room temp. before using it. For a couple of days the atta will stay good in an air-tight container.
Happy Diwali!
[Reply]
October 23rd, 2009 at 8:30 pm
1. How long does it take to initially knead the
dough? From the video, it looks like you have to
work at it for a while.
2. Thanks so much for this much needed, basic
recipe.
3. =)
[Reply]
hetal Reply:
October 24th, 2009 at 12:19 am
Hi Ami,
It really only takes about 1-2 minutes to knead roti dough. You really don’t want to over work it and release a lot of gluten. It’ll make the roti chewy.
[Reply]
November 1st, 2009 at 2:40 am
I was wondering is there any reason that oil is not added with the atta when making the dough. I noticed that you add oil when making the chapati dough but not the phulka. Finally your videos are great i am a student and it saves me time and money and your videos have thought me to make healthy and good food. Thanks a lot
[Reply]
hetal Reply:
November 3rd, 2009 at 9:50 pm
Hi Bala,
We’re glad you’re enjoying our videos! We have two versions of roti — Rotli and Phulka. Rotli is a gujarati version that has oil in the dough. It is great for when you have to eat the roti a bit later…it remains soft. Phulka is more of a north Indian style roti that does not have oil. It must be eaten right away. Different regions make things differently so we are providing options. Here is the link for Rotli – http://showmethecurry.com/breads/rotli-roti-indian-bread-recipe.html
[Reply]
November 13th, 2009 at 1:11 am
hi Hetal and Anuja
though i dont post here regularly but i am fan of your receipes. I am looking for indian foods (Chapati, cooked rice etc) which does not have folic acid or folates? it is important for me not to eat this for quite a while. for the last few days i have been eating only dairy products plus apple. i am already starving.
any help for me is greatly appreciated.
[Reply]
December 30th, 2009 at 11:32 pm
Hi – I’ve just seen the demonstration of a method of cooking naan on a mesh in direct heat on a stove top.
Can you please tell me what the mesh is called so I can buy one ?
G.
[Reply]
hetal Reply:
January 2nd, 2010 at 11:32 pm
Hi G,
It is called a splatter screen.
[Reply]
January 20th, 2010 at 8:40 pm
Hi Hetal and Anjua . I have a small request . Please can u show us how to make rice roti. I tried one time and had to throw all the dough in the dustbin. I was very unhappy. I know u are very busy. No hurry u can take your own time. I have electric stove not a fire one is that a problem just wondering if i can make rice rotis on electric stove. Love u both bye. Please do reply.
[Reply]
February 14th, 2010 at 4:34 am
hi…..
i liked the way ur phulka puffed up… i bought a mesh with handle from indian store…. it is little thicker than the splatter screen …. will phulka turn out good on it… please reply soon…. as i really want to try and learn to make phulkas
thanks …
[Reply]
hetal Reply:
February 15th, 2010 at 4:20 pm
Hi Nusrat,
If the mesh is from the Indian store, it is probably meant to be used for rotis — so it should work. Basically, you have to increase the heat to make the rotis puff up.
[Reply]
March 2nd, 2010 at 5:03 pm
HI dear sisters…
today i maked phulka…its not balloon up full like urs,:( but some spotts only cm like dat…..i follow al like u..butphulka is v soft…n tasty but only no salty taste..i want to knw y ur not using salt for this…then it will taste more knw..pls reply me..
[Reply]
hetal Reply:
March 2nd, 2010 at 6:31 pm
Hi Shahira,
Many people do not add salt in their rotis. Sounds like you would like our Rotli recipe better. Here is the link: http://showmethecurry.com/breads/rotli-roti-indian-bread-recipe.html
[Reply]
May 11th, 2010 at 1:04 pm
Please continue to post some basic recipes too which makes day to day cooking easier. your recipes are interesting.
[Reply]
May 21st, 2010 at 12:27 am
sweet sanjaya my phulkas burn really fast and some of them dont really puff up that good. guess need a little more practice
[Reply]
July 23rd, 2010 at 8:13 pm
When you cater to a wide audience, it is difficult to please everyone. I enjoy your site and your recipes and thank you for sharing them. A lot of folks just wont share their recipes. You are kind enough to do so, and from those of us who appreciate the two of you a BIG THANK YOU.
[Reply]
September 10th, 2010 at 10:31 pm
Can anyone suggest the best atta brand in US to get soft phulkas, rotis, parathas? Ive tried many but not sure which one is really good. Any suggestions?
[Reply]
hetal Reply:
September 11th, 2010 at 3:00 pm
Hi Preethi,
We have had good results with Laxmi brand atta.
[Reply]
Preethi Reply:
September 11th, 2010 at 7:41 pm
thanks a lot Hetal
[Reply]
September 30th, 2010 at 3:24 am
Hi Laddies,
Could news my roti turned out perfect =) I let the dough chill over night and its seems to work well. Its most probably the atta brand. What would be nice to eat with roti and do you have a video on Bhakri? thanks again for your help and suggestion and keep up the good work =)
[Reply]
hetal Reply:
September 30th, 2010 at 2:44 pm
Hi Gorona,
Rotis can be enjoyed with any dry vegetable dish or any of the curries. We do not have a video for Bhakri, yet
.
[Reply]
November 16th, 2010 at 9:25 am
What a great site! My husband I are living in China right now and missing some of our favorite Indian restaurants back in Seattle. I decided to head out today to see what ingredients I could find in our rural town. While very limited, I will be trying a curry and this phulka for dinner tonight–my fist ever attempt at Indian cuisine. The videos are wonderful and so easy to follow.
Thanks so much for sharing your recipes and knowledge with the world!
[Reply]
hetal Reply:
November 18th, 2010 at 7:50 pm
Hi Heather,
Glad you found us! Hope you were successful!
[Reply]
January 9th, 2011 at 1:40 am
Hi Anuja and Hetal,
. One question, now a days we get so many choices of wheat flour. Which brand is good for taste and which one is healthier?
I learned cooking by watching your show. I also enjoyed bloopers on youtube
[Reply]
anuja Reply:
January 12th, 2011 at 4:37 am
Hi Abhijit,
Now when possible I combine it with Laxmi and everyone is happy. The bad news is that Sujata Multigrain is hard to come by…
Are you asking about Chapati Atta? Well, if you are – then the answer – we use Laxmi brand and really like it. I have used Sujata Multigrain Atta once and liked the flavor and the fact that it was healthier but no one in my family liked the color of the Chapatis
Hope that helps!
[Reply]
March 4th, 2011 at 9:46 am
Hey Hetal and Anuja,
I have been watching your cooking recipes from quiet long. Tried phulka last week and believe me all my phulkas ballooned up. They were really soft and so nice to eat. I am making them regularly now. My husband loved the phulkas too. Thank you so much!
[Reply]
April 8th, 2011 at 6:26 pm
Hi,
I recently purchased a magic bullet and one of the recipes in the booklet that came with it is of a flapjack which asks for milk, egg and pancake mix in required proportions to be blend. My question is that if I can make pancake dough with my magic bullet, can I make atta too?
[Reply]
May 25th, 2011 at 12:32 pm
Just to know, is it better to use warm water for kneading the atta than normal water (room temp)..?
[Reply]
hetal Reply:
May 25th, 2011 at 10:25 pm
Hi Jeena,
Yes, we always use slightly warm water for kneading any kind of dough. The texture comes out better.
[Reply]
June 5th, 2011 at 10:03 pm
hi hetal and anuja,
I want to know where can i get insulated container for chapatis.
[Reply]
June 6th, 2011 at 10:15 pm
hi hetal,
i want to buy insulated container please tell me where can i get.
please give me response.
[Reply]
July 14th, 2011 at 10:11 pm
Hey Hi Hetal & Anuja
i wanted to know how to make frozen phulka or roti should i just store them in freezer or add something in dough or should keep in aluminum foil plz help me
[Reply]
hetal Reply:
July 17th, 2011 at 12:18 am
Hi Soniya,
If you want to freeze the roti, try our recipe for Rotli (it has oil in the dough). You can roll out the rotis and keep a small piece of parchment paper or wax paper in between each roti. Place the whole stack in a freezer style ziploc bag and freeze.
[Reply]
soniya Reply:
July 19th, 2011 at 6:22 pm
Thank you so much hetal
[Reply]
September 22nd, 2011 at 2:54 am
hi!
can i make roti dough in bulk, like the chapati in bulk?
thanks!
[Reply]
hetal Reply:
September 22nd, 2011 at 5:07 pm
Hi Shruti,
Yes, you can also make roti dough in bulk. Same process.
[Reply]
shruti Reply:
September 23rd, 2011 at 3:10 pm
Thanks so much for responding and thanks for doing such a wonderful job. I have a recipe which I would like to share. where can I send?
[Reply]
hetal Reply:
September 23rd, 2011 at 7:31 pm
You can send it to anuja@showmethecurry.com or/and hetal@showmethecurry.com.
shruti Reply:
September 23rd, 2011 at 3:13 pm
also, one more thing, would you add oil in the dough to make it in bulk?
[Reply]
hetal Reply:
September 23rd, 2011 at 7:32 pm
Hi Shruti,
Oil is not necessary but if you want to add it, you can follow our Rotli recipe.
December 15th, 2011 at 11:23 pm
Hi
Whenever i try to make roti they are never even. How do you roll them so they are even and round?
[Reply]
hetal Reply:
December 19th, 2011 at 4:29 am
Hi Raj,
There is no easy answer… to make them round, its practice, practice and more practice
To get them even, my mom always taught me to feel the roti with my hand as I am rolling it. You will instantly feel where it is too thick or thin and then you can fix it.
[Reply]
raj Reply:
December 19th, 2011 at 2:31 pm
Thanks for the reply. I have another question if you don’t mind.
When rolling the roti are you suppose to move the belan slightly round as you go up and down? Or do you only move the belan up and down and the roti should automatically move around by itself?
[Reply]
hetal Reply:
January 3rd, 2012 at 5:09 pm
Hi Raj,
Everyone has a different way of rolling. I make sure there is enough dry flour on the dough so that it does not stick to the surface at all. I move my hands in a clockwise motion as I am going up and down. This way, the roti increases in size in a round shape and not a square shape.
March 20th, 2012 at 9:33 pm
Hi Hetail & Anuja,
I have been trying to make soft phulkas/roties for some months now. I have an electric stove and I use a mesh to make the phulkas puff up. Even though they puff up very well, my phulkas are very hard and taste raw…
I usually make the aataa in bulk and store it in the fridge.However, I do not add oil to it. I take it out a couple of hours before making the roties such that it is not tight but still when I make the roties, they come out hard n raw… not sure where I am going wrong….
[Reply]
Aarzoo Reply:
March 21st, 2012 at 12:19 pm
Btw, I use Ashirwaad aata…. also, usually my aata is slightly on the loose side. Could that be the reason?
Any guidance that you could provide will be great!
Best Regards,
[Reply]
hetal Reply:
March 21st, 2012 at 1:13 pm
Hi Aarzoo,
I have not tried Aashirwaad brand atta but that should not be the reason. Btw, we use Laxmi brand atta. One trick to keeping the rotis soft is to keep them in an insulated container until you are ready to eat. This phulka recipe does not have oil in the dough so the phulkas must be eaten immediately after being made. If you plan on eating them after a bit, try our Rotli recipe (with oil in the dough). Here it is: http://showmethecurry.com/breads/rotli-roti-indian-bread-recipe.html
Regarding the raw taste, try to cook the roti a bit more before trying to puff it. The intense heat from the electric element may be cooking it too fast before it has time to actually cook the dough.
[Reply]